SAFE’S Center for Critical Minerals Strategy Comments on BIS Rule to Restrict Export of Tungsten and Black Mass Waste and Scrap

On November 4, 2026, SAFE’s Center for Critical Minerals Strategy responded to the Bureau of Industry and Security’s (BIS) request for comments for the temporary final rule to restrict the exportation of black mass and tungsten waste and scrap without a license.

SAFE’s Minerals Center supports efforts to strengthen domestic recovery of critical minerals and materials (CMMs) from black mass, rare-earth permanent magnets, swarf, and other recycling feedstocks. Recovering these materials can supplement primary production, help reduce import dependence, and address supply chain vulnerabilities that pose risks to U.S. national security.

However, through it’s research “Retain, Recycle, Secure,” SAFE has found that export restrictions alone cannot address the capital, operating, technical, and regulatory challenges that constrain domestic recycling capacity. Greater attention is also needed to strengthen collection systems and channel more end-of-life materials into recycling streams, particularly copper, rare earth permanent magnets, and batteries embedded in electronic waste. Export restrictions should therefore be complemented by policies that address these other hurdles to translate greater feedstock availability into increased domestic CMM production.

There is a need for:

  1. Clearer Guidance to Address Enforcement Challenges
  2. Timely License Processing to Sustain the Domestic Recycling Ecosystem
  3. Traceability and Complementary Policies to Address Challenges Like Diversion Risks
    Associated with Mixed Feedstocks
  4. Flexibility to Respond to Evolving Recycling Markets and Supply Chains

Read SAFE’s full comments here.