SAFE’s Center for Strategic Industrial Materials’ report, Strategic Loads: America’s Aluminum Deficit is an Energy Problem, finds that the decline of U.S. primary aluminum production is fundamentally a challenge of electricity cost and reliability. Action to ensure long-term affordable, reliable power is essential to reverse the decades-long decline in domestic capacity and meet the needs of defense and wartime mobilization.
Tariffs and stronger aluminum prices have helped spur new investment, but they do not generate power. Sustaining domestic production also requires reliable electricity on commercially viable terms.
The report identifies four challenges:
- Defense aluminum depends on a healthy commercial base. Aluminum is essential for airframes, munitions, and other defense applications. Defense procurement accounts for only about five percent of domestic primary aluminum demand, but no smelter can operate economically on defense demand alone. Defense metal is a byproduct of a commercially viable industry.
- Smelting demands affordable, resilient power. Smelting consumes 13 to 16 megawatt-hours (MWh) of electricity per metric ton, and power accounts for roughly 40 percent of production costs.
- Smelters now compete with data centers for power. A new smelter requires decades of electricity priced near $40 per MWh. U.S. industrial rates averaged $81 per MWh in 2024, and data centers have demonstrated the ability to sustain operations near $115 per MWh. Smelters and data centers are also competing for the same interconnection rights, and smelters are losing. The last U.S. smelter capable of producing high-purity aluminum for defense applications was idled in 2022, citing high power costs. Its site was bought in February 2026 for data center redevelopment.
- The supply gap is large and growing. The United States was once the world’s largest producer of primary aluminum. Today, China accounts for roughly 60 percent of global output, only five U.S. primary smelters remain in operation, and roughly 84 percent of the primary aluminum the country consumes is imported. By 2029, only 16 percent of the primary aluminum consumed in the U.S. will be produced domestically.
Domestic Aluminum Production and National Security
A 2025 Department of War wargame instructed participants to plan for a fivefold increase in defense demand for aluminum in a hypothetical conflict. For 2029, that would mean rising from roughly 255,000 metric tons in peacetime to about 1.28 million metric tons in a wartime contingency. However, supply cannot surge with demand. Restarting a curtailed potline takes months, and building a greenfield smelter takes the better part of a decade. The capacity that exists when a conflict begins is the capacity available for its duration.
SAFE Calls for Congressional and Federal Action
The United States must build an energy system that sustains and grows its domestic manufacturing while also facilitating the rapid growth of artificial intelligence if it is to maintain its economic strength, technological leadership, and national security advantage.
Strategic Loads recommends the following actions for Congress, the federal government, utilities, and smelters:
- Congress should authorize a targeted, price-indexed power cost offset for aluminum capacity necessary to meet defense and mobilization requirements.
- Congress should appropriate funds to help modernize the smelter fleet, improve energy efficiency, and reduce the long-term cost of maintaining strategic capacity.
- The Department of War and Department of Energy should designate defense critical industrial loads and expedite their access to critical energy infrastructure.
- Utilities and smelters should work to increase power flexibility.
- The U.S. government should treat scrap as a strategic asset and expand domestic secondary production.
- Congress should require the Secretary of War to report on the state of the aluminum industry.

